Success of new vocational pathway depends on employers being able to offer 43,500 placements but capacity and costs constraints are holding them back- Make UK/EngineeringUK analysis
With a chronic shortage of skilled technicians to power Britain’s industry, it is critical that more employers get on board with T levels and offer industry placements, to plug the gap and give UK business the power it needs to compete on the international stage.
To coincide with National T Levels Week, Make UK and EngineeringUK have published new research highlighting the benefits of T levels for businesses who are desperate for more young skilled people. However, the report - Unlocking talent: Ensuring T levels deliver the workforce of the future also draws attention to the challenges that T levels in the engineering and manufacturing sector face, particularly the industry placement component of the qualification.
Make UK and EngineeringUK estimate that the engineering and manufacturing T level route will require as many as 43,500 placements to be provided by employers in the sector by 2024/25. Yet currently only 1 in 10 (9%) of engineering and manufacturing employers surveyed for the report hosts a T level placement and just 12% plan to in the coming year.
Several factors are holding back engineering and manufacturing employers from engaging with T levels and from offering industry placements, including a lack of employer understanding of T levels and of information and support on offer. The survey found that over half (52%) of respondents had never heard of the financial support available for offering placements. Almost 6 in 10 (57%) said that they had not heard of the tailored advice and hands-on direct support available, with 52% saying the same about webinars, guides and case studies, and 63% about shared placements.
But it’s not just awareness, cost and capacity remain a major barrier, with 44% of engineering and manufacturing businesses saying a lack of staff capacity is the main barrier to delivering T level industry placements. Time commitment (41%) was the second most significant barrier for employers, while a fifth have concerns about legal constraints, extending to adequate protection of young people in safety-critical industries.
Three in 10 employers (29%) told us that they already offered apprenticeships was a barrier to them being able to offer T level industry placements, increasing to 34% for the largest businesses.
That said, employers remain of the view that T levels have the potential to provide a solution to solving their vocational pipeline issues with 55% open to taking on an industry placement in the future.
To secure more industry placements government action is needed to remove the barriers facing employers offering them. More than half (57%) of manufacturers said that reinstating the £1,000 financial incentive would make the most notable difference to their ability to offer placements and 2 in 5 said integrating T levels with apprenticeships would help them offer to placements.
Make UK and EngineeringUK are calling on government to:
- Restore the £1,000 incentive for SMEs to make it easier for employers to offer a T level placement
- Work with sector bodies and organisations to run an awareness raising campaign to get more employers on board
- Develop clear progression maps that demonstrate how T levels work within the current education landscape
- Establish a T level industry placement taskforce to support the delivery of placements and be ambassadors for the wider T level programme
Bhavina Bharkhada, Head of Policy & Campaigns at Make UK said:
“More than ever the manufacturing industry is crying out for skilled technicians, data scientists and technical operators. The pipeline from the EU has been severely curtailed since the UK left the European Union, so we need to turbocharge the best quality training in these skills from homegrown talent.
For too long apprenticeships and vocational careers in our great industries have been viewed as second best, and the creation of T levels as a qualification of choice will go some way in delivering the very best in life opportunities, which is critical to changing perceptions and delivering the skills Britain so badly needs.”
Although T levels have been under development for some time, 28% of employers still have not heard of the new qualification. More than half (52%) say they would benefit from more tailored information and guidance, including at a local level. Government should go further in tailoring T Level resources to employers in the sector, establish a T level industry placement taskforce and promote T levels across government to improve awareness and understanding.
Beatrice Barleon, Head of Policy & Public Affairs, Engineering UK
‘The UK urgently needs more engineers and technicians to drive innovation and support economic growth as well as our ambitions around net zero. But as it stands, we have far too few young people coming up through the education system wanting and able to move into a career in engineering and manufacturing.
T levels are designed to provide young people with a clear pathway into engineering and manufacturing careers, but their success hinges on young people being able to access industry placements as part of their qualifications. As it stands, it will be a real challenge to secure the 43,500 placements needed.
We are therefore urging government to focus on supporting businesses and education providers through offering financial incentives as well as creating the right conditions and frameworks. Doing so will enable them to collaborate efficiently and open up their businesses for young people to learn new skills and develop into the workforce of the future that we so desperately need.'
About Make UK
Make UK, the manufacturers’ organisation, is the representative voice of UK manufacturing, with offices in London, Brussels, every English region and Wales.
Collectively we represent 20,000 companies of all sizes, from start-ups to multinationals, across engineering, manufacturing, technology and the wider industrial sector. We directly represent over 5,000 businesses who are members of Make UK. Everything we do – from providing essential business support and training to championing manufacturing industry in the UK and the EU – is designed to help British manufacturers compete, innovate and grow.
From HR and employment law, health and safety to environmental and productivity improvement, our advice, expertise and influence enables businesses to remain safe, compliant and future-focused.
EngineeringUK is a not-for-profit organisation that works in partnership with the engineering community to inspire tomorrow’s engineers. We bring engineering careers inspiration and resources together through Tomorrow’s Engineers and manage The Tomorrow’s Engineers Code, which drives change at scale to increase the number and diversity of young people choosing academic and vocational pathways into engineering. We lead the engagement programmes: The Big Bang, Robotics Challenge and Energy Quest and help schools bring STEM to life through real-world engineering via Neon. We base everything we do on evidence and share our insight widely.